« The Applied Economics Blog | Main | Fly me to the moon And let me play among the stars »
March 28, 2006
An immodest proposal
What if we scrapped the welfare state and gave every adult $10,000 per year instead?
That's Charles Murray's idea to replace the entire welfare state.
It starts off more expensive than the current system, but by 2011 (just 5 years!) it ends up cheaper. He proposes that $3000 per year has to be spent on a no-increase health insurance plan in the form of a reverse annuity. $2000 goes towards a stock and bond market invested mutual fund.
If we have to take communal responsibility for the welfare of others using the tyrannical power of the state, then is is a way to do it.
We could abolish poverty, keep overhead costs lo, and w give people the freedom to spend in ways that reflect their values while preventing their personal problems from becoming more expensive public ones later. That reflects a harmonization of popular American values like frugality, a love of freedom, and communal responsibility for the less fortunate among us.
$5000 shouldn't be so much money that it provides much of an incentive to avoid work, but in these days of Walmart should keep families with couples fed and clothed. A modest amount of additional work can catapult a family above the poverty line.
With this policy in place, a family of two adults and two children only has to raise another $8,000 a year to live above the poverty line. At the minimum wage of $5.15, that's 32 hours a week plus 2 weeks vacation a year for one parent and the other parent not working. All the while building real savings for retirement.
But what an amazing disruption. There are about 1.7 million civilian employees for the federal government, excluding the post office. Could 10% be cut be abolishing housing aid, Medicare, Medicaid, and Social Security? Health and human services, HUD, and the SSA employ 136,000 people. There's got to be more savings in there someplace. This could also encourage states to follow suit, leading to additional disruptions.
All those regulations left unwritten, easily over a hundred thousand talented people freed up to go into the labor market, what an exciting possibility. He details it more extensively in his new book, In Our Hands: A Plan to Replace the Welfare State
Posted by OneEyedMan at March 28, 2006 8:34 AM
Comments
Post a comment
Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)
(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)